EB-5 denials, NOIDs & litigation

Challenge an EB-5 denial with the right strategy.

We represent EB-5 investors responding to Notices of Intent to Deny, evaluating motions and AAO appeals after I-526 or I-526E denials, pursuing judicial review when available, and preparing for I-829 review in immigration court.

Start with the notice

What did USCIS issue in your EB-5 case?

A NOID, an I-526 or I-526E denial, and an I-829 denial arise at different stages. The record, deadline, burden, and available forum can change with the case posture.

Protect the deadline before choosing the remedy. The notice, service method and date, current filing instructions, and procedural history should be reviewed immediately. Under 8 C.F.R. § 103.5(a)(1)(iv), a motion generally does not stay the decision or extend another deadline.
Discuss your notice

Do not send confidential documents before the firm confirms representation. An inquiry alone does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Strategy begins with posture

An EB-5 denial is a serious setback – but it may not be the final word.

One record. Different standards, forums, and paths of review.

An EB-5 denial is not evaluated in the abstract. The available strategy depends on which petition was denied, what USCIS placed in the administrative record, who bears the burden of proof, which deadlines and exhaustion requirements apply, and whether review proceeds before the AAO, a federal court, or an Immigration Judge.

An I-829 removal proceeding may permit relevant evidence beyond the USCIS file, while federal-court review of an I-526 or I-526E denial is ordinarily confined to the administrative record. These distinctions can shape the evidence to develop, the arguments to preserve, the forum to pursue, and the range of possible outcomes.

Responding to an EB-5 NOID

Build the record while there is still time.

A Notice of Intent to Deny is not simply another request for documents. It identifies the issues that may define an appeal, motion, removal proceeding, or later federal-court challenge.

Forum matters. An effective NOID response does more than answer USCIS for the present decision; it builds the record for the forum that may follow. In removal proceedings after an I-829 denial, the Immigration Judge may consider relevant evidence beyond the USCIS file. When judicial review is available after an I-526 or I-526E denial, the federal court ordinarily evaluates USCIS’s action on the administrative record rather than through a new evidentiary proceeding.
  1. Preserve the complete record

    Collect the original petition, project filing, RFEs, NOIDs, responses, source-and-path documents, bank records, economic reports, and contemporaneous communications.

  2. Map every allegation

    Separate source of funds, ownership and path, deployment, sustainment, job creation, project changes, and any fraud or misrepresentation concern.

  3. Reconcile the evidence

    Test names, dates, account numbers, transfers, tax reporting, job allocations, and business records for unexplained inconsistencies.

  4. Use the right expertise

    When appropriate, preserve testimony and engage forensic accounting, economic, construction, or other project expertise before records and witnesses become unavailable.

  5. Build for both paths

    Answer each stated concern, connect every fact to the evidence, explain why any record is unavailable, and preserve legal arguments. A complete submission strengthens the administrative record for federal review and prepares the evidence for immigration court if needed.

I-526 and I-526E denials

Choose the remedy. Build the administrative record.

A denial can put years of planning, invested capital, and a family’s immigration strategy at risk. An effective response begins by identifying what went wrong: missing or misunderstood evidence, legal error, flawed agency reasoning, or a combination of issues.

Available procedures

Motions, AAO appeals, and federal-court review

Motion to reopen

Present new facts and evidence

A motion to reopen asks the USCIS authority responsible for the latest decision to consider new facts supported by affidavits or other documentary evidence. It may fit a denial that can be addressed with missing, clarifying, or newly assembled proof.

Motion to reconsider

Identify legal or policy error

A motion to reconsider argues that USCIS incorrectly applied law or policy based on the record that existed when it decided the case. It should identify the error precisely and support the argument with governing authority.

AAO appeal

Seek administrative appellate review

The deciding office first reviews the appeal and may take favorable action. Otherwise, the case proceeds to the AAO, which independently reexamines factual and legal issues and may consider additional evidence. The process is generally written and record-based.

Federal court

Challenge unlawful agency action

For determinations covered by the current EB-5 statute, judicial review generally requires exhaustion of administrative appeals. When review is available, the court ordinarily evaluates whether the agency acted lawfully based on the administrative record.

A motion to reopen and a motion to reconsider may be combined, but USCIS evaluates each under its own requirements. Appeals, motions, and court actions also differ in deadlines, evidence, finality, and available relief.
Evidence

Close real gaps

Trace ownership and transfers, corroborate the immediate source, and resolve material discrepancies.

Whole record

Show why the evidence matters

Organize the proof around relevance, credibility, and the totality of the record.

Correct stage

Separate projections from outcomes

Test whether USCIS applied the requirements governing the petition’s adjudicatory stage.

Materiality

Connect change to eligibility

Explain whether a change affects capital at risk, job creation, or another governing requirement.

Detailed legal analysisStandards, evidence, materiality, and source-of-funds issues

Standard and record

Standard of proof and the administrative record

On appeal, the investor retains the burden to establish eligibility by a preponderance of the evidence. The AAO reviews factual and legal issues de novo and generally decides I-526 and I-526E appeals from the written submissions and record of proceedings.

Additional evidence may be submitted on appeal, but it must establish that the investor was eligible when the petition was filed and remained eligible throughout adjudication. Building a complete record matters because federal-court review, when available, is ordinarily based on that record.

Preponderance is a weighing standard – not a document-counting exercise. Matter of Chawathe directs USCIS to evaluate relevance, probative value, and credibility, individually and within the totality of the evidence.

Eligibility at filing

Job-creation evidence and the correct adjudicatory stage

At the I-526 or I-526E stage, the investor ordinarily shows how the required jobs will be created; the jobs need not all exist when the petition is filed. A credible business plan should explain the enterprise, staffing needs, and hiring timetable, while regional-center filings may rely on a permitted economic methodology.

Evidence of jobs already created can strengthen the record, but it is not the only permissible proof. The petition must still establish eligibility at filing; later project success cannot cure a plan that was deficient when submitted.

Materiality

Project changes and continuing eligibility

Projects evolve, and a delay or modification is not disqualifying by itself. The central question is whether new facts explain how the plan presented at filing is being carried out or instead replace a fact on which eligibility depended.

An appeal should identify what changed and when, explain why, and use contemporaneous project and economic evidence to show any effect on the investment structure, deployment of capital, business-plan credibility, and projected jobs.

Lawful source and path

Tracing funds and reconstructing unavailable records

In Battineni v. Mayorkas, a D.D.C. district court applying legacy I-526 rules rejected a categorical requirement to trace funds beyond the investor’s immediate source, while leaving one denial in place where the evidence did not adequately establish that an immediate source was lawful.

The decision did not eliminate tracing. Investors must still prove ownership and lawful source, and petitions governed by the EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act face additional statutory requirements for certain gifts, loans, and transfers.

When original records no longer exist because of age, disaster, or retention limits, the response should document the search and the reason, then connect declarations and reconstructions to available bank evidence, public records, and other contemporaneous corroboration.

I-829 denials

I-829 denial review in immigration court

There is no direct AAO appeal from an I-829 denial. A motion may be evaluated, and review of the denial may proceed before an Immigration Judge once removal proceedings are initiated.

The Ninth Circuit explained in Chang v. United States that the I-829 process confirms whether the investor fulfilled the plan approved at the I-526 stage rather than beginning the original petition analysis again. The case arose under a legacy framework and within the Ninth Circuit.

USCIS policy generally provides for deference to prior favorable determinations when the underlying facts remain unchanged, subject to recognized exceptions such as material change, fraud or willful misrepresentation, or a legally deficient prior decision.

How review can proceed

The USCIS file frames the dispute. The judge determines how the record develops.

01

The USCIS record is the starting point

The petition, project filing, NOID response, denial, and supporting documents frame the issues for review.

02

Additional evidence may be considered

The Immigration Judge may consider relevant documents and testimony not previously presented to USCIS.

03

Written record or live evidence

Some matters may be addressed through pleadings and documents; unresolved disputes may require witnesses or experts.

04

The statutory burden matters

For a merits-based denial of a properly filed I-829, the government bears the burden specified by 8 U.S.C. § 1186b.

Investment

Investment and sustainment

Whether the required capital was invested, deployed, and continuously maintained during conditional residence.

Jobs

Job creation

Economic methodology, expenditure records, construction evidence, payroll, timing, and allocation among investors.

Changes

Project changes

Whether changes occurred, when they were conceived, why they were made, and how they affect eligibility.

Prior findings

Source-of-funds questions

Why USCIS is revisiting a previously approved issue, whether a deference exception applies, and how older evidence can be reconstructed and tested.

Integrated representation

A coordinated team for the agency record, federal court, and immigration court.

An EB-5 denial can require different forms of legal work at different stages. The team assigns each issue to the experience it calls for while keeping the investor’s immigration and financial objectives in view.

  • Pavel L. ParomovEB-5 strategy, motions to reopen or reconsider, mandamus actions, and investor-side securities issues.
  • Alina VoronovComplex federal litigation, including mandamus complaints and petitions for review.
  • Katherine BekasovaNOID and denial responses, briefs, legal arguments, and memoranda for immigration proceedings.
  • Pei Ying HoMandarin-language assistance for Chinese clients navigating complex EB-5 matters.
  • Hon. William P. JoyceRepresentation before Immigration Judges in removal proceedings, informed by his prior service as a U.S. Immigration Judge.
Meet the team

Questions investors ask

Know the forum before choosing the strategy.

What should I do after receiving an EB-5 NOID?

Preserve the deadline, obtain the complete filing history, and map every allegation to the evidence and governing rule. Do not alter original records. When a document is unavailable, document the search and identify reliable corroborating evidence.

Can an I-526 or I-526E denial be appealed?

Generally, yes. An AAO appeal or a motion to reopen or reconsider may be available. The AAO independently reviews factual and legal issues, but the investor retains the burden of proof. The decision notice and current filing instructions control the available path and deadline.

What is the difference between an AAO appeal and a motion?

An appeal asks the AAO to review the denial after the deciding office conducts its initial field review. A motion asks the authority responsible for the latest decision to reopen the case for new facts and evidence, reconsider an asserted legal or policy error on the existing record, or do both. The best procedural choice depends on the denial, the evidence, and the objective.

Can I go directly to federal court after an I-526 or I-526E denial?

Current law generally requires exhaustion of all available administrative appeals before a court may review a covered EB-5 determination. A motion to reopen or reconsider does not replace the AAO appeal required to preserve judicial review. Jurisdiction, finality, and timing require case-specific analysis.

Will a federal court consider new evidence?

Ordinarily, a federal court reviews the certified administrative record and does not consider evidence submitted for the first time in court. That is why evidence and legal arguments should be developed at the NOID, motion, and appeal stages whenever possible.

Does filing Form I-290B suspend the denial?

Generally, filing a motion to reopen or reconsider does not stay execution of the decision. The denial notice, the effect on the investor’s status, and every potentially applicable deadline should be reviewed separately and immediately.

Can an I-829 denial be appealed to the AAO?

No direct AAO appeal lies from an I-829 denial. The investor may seek review in removal proceedings after USCIS terminates conditional residence and issues a Notice to Appear. A motion to reopen or reconsider may also be evaluated depending on the facts and timing.

Does every I-829 review require a trial?

Not necessarily. Counsel may ask the Immigration Judge to decide the review from pleadings, admissions, briefs, and documentary evidence when the record resolves the relevant issues. The judge controls the procedure and may receive testimony or expert evidence when material questions remain. That is why counsel should build the record for both paths from the outset.

Why can source of funds return at the I-829 stage?

USCIS generally gives deference to prior favorable determinations, but it may revisit an issue when it asserts a recognized exception or identifies derogatory information. The response should test the legal basis for reopening the issue and address any legitimate evidentiary concern.

Legal information, not a prediction. Every NOID and denial turns on its own record, governing law, filing date, and procedural posture. Prior decisions – including favorable decisions – do not guarantee a similar result.

Start with the notice

Received an EB-5 NOID or denial?

Preserve every deadline and gather the denial or NOID, service date, complete petition, RFE or NOID responses, and supporting record for a focused review.

Discuss the next step

Do not send confidential documents before the firm confirms representation. An inquiry alone does not create an attorney-client relationship.