Standard and record
Standard of proof and the administrative record
On appeal, the investor retains the burden to establish eligibility by a preponderance of the evidence. The AAO reviews factual and legal issues de novo and generally decides I-526 and I-526E appeals from the written submissions and record of proceedings.
Additional evidence may be submitted on appeal, but it must establish that the investor was eligible when the petition was filed and remained eligible throughout adjudication. Building a complete record matters because federal-court review, when available, is ordinarily based on that record.
Preponderance is a weighing standard – not a document-counting exercise. Matter of Chawathe directs USCIS to evaluate relevance, probative value, and credibility, individually and within the totality of the evidence.
Eligibility at filing
Job-creation evidence and the correct adjudicatory stage
At the I-526 or I-526E stage, the investor ordinarily shows how the required jobs will be created; the jobs need not all exist when the petition is filed. A credible business plan should explain the enterprise, staffing needs, and hiring timetable, while regional-center filings may rely on a permitted economic methodology.
Evidence of jobs already created can strengthen the record, but it is not the only permissible proof. The petition must still establish eligibility at filing; later project success cannot cure a plan that was deficient when submitted.
Materiality
Project changes and continuing eligibility
Projects evolve, and a delay or modification is not disqualifying by itself. The central question is whether new facts explain how the plan presented at filing is being carried out or instead replace a fact on which eligibility depended.
An appeal should identify what changed and when, explain why, and use contemporaneous project and economic evidence to show any effect on the investment structure, deployment of capital, business-plan credibility, and projected jobs.
Lawful source and path
Tracing funds and reconstructing unavailable records
In Battineni v. Mayorkas, a D.D.C. district court applying legacy I-526 rules rejected a categorical requirement to trace funds beyond the investor’s immediate source, while leaving one denial in place where the evidence did not adequately establish that an immediate source was lawful.
The decision did not eliminate tracing. Investors must still prove ownership and lawful source, and petitions governed by the EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act face additional statutory requirements for certain gifts, loans, and transfers.
When original records no longer exist because of age, disaster, or retention limits, the response should document the search and the reason, then connect declarations and reconstructions to available bank evidence, public records, and other contemporaneous corroboration.